HC Judge’s View on Judiciary (Worth Reading)

Standard

People have strange perception about judiciary.

It worth to know what High Court Judges think.

Recently I had talk a prominent Senior Advocate a retired Madhya Pradesh HIgh Court Judge .

According to him, law is an art but it is not a satisfactory art.

It is very very difficult to do justice in accordance with law.

A feeling always remains in heart of a judge that something has remained incomplete.

That is why people go into appeal to one court after another court.

Lawyers have same feeling when case is over that something was yet to be pleaded.

Thus, though law is an art is not a satisfactory art. It is so easy for parties to throw allegations against judges.

But it is very difficult to do justice in accordance with law.

In every case, something good is seen and suddenly some very bad facts come up in evidence.

Each case is a challenge to do justice in accordance with law.

12/3/13

Legal IQ puzzle: Does word "Relative of Husband" used in 113A,B include "Brother in Law of Husband- i e Brother of Wife" ?

Standard

Within seven years of marriage, if wife commits suited, Husband or HIS RELATIVE will be deemed to have abated suicide.113A,B of Evidence Act.

But suppose in a given case, if wife has committed suicide due to torturous attitude of his own brother, will sec.113A,B apply to brother of wife, who is also a brother in law of husband(RELATIVE OF HUSBAND) as mentioned in 113A,B?

1) Where the words “Relative” or “Relative of Husband” are defined?

2) On what legal reasoning basis it can be said that words “Relative of Husband” do not include his brother in law, sister in law and Mother in law?

Haresh Raichura
9/3/13